
I teach a class on Design Thinking as an elective for 7th and 8th graders. Throughout the semester, we go through about 4-5 different design challenges. Aspects of each of these challenges make up the students’ grades. While these projects are designed for a class structure, they can easily be adapted for a Makerspace Club, collaboration with another class in the library, or as a special afterschool event.
I like to create design challenges for students that combine multiple elements of design thinking into the project. For the Board Game project, students are learning about 3D printing and design. They are learning about how to incorporate educational elements into a game. Students are thinking about the clients they are designing for and how their game can be fun and entertaining while also teaching about something. Overall, it’s a super fun challenge and my students always come up with amazing designs for it.
Make a Board Game: The Design Prompt
For this project, you will be designing and 3D printing a board game that is playable by 2-4 people. This board game should teach the person playing about something about a topic (math, science, vocabulary, sports, a topic you’re interested in, etc). You’ll use TinkerCAD for the 3D design and your project can incorporate recycled materials as well. Students can work individually or in groups of up to three students. Ideas for the 3D printed element include, but aren’t limited to: dice, spinner, game pieces, etc.
Your board game should include a name, instructions that explains how to play, and a goal to finish. It should be a game that is easy to understand how to play and that takes less than ten minutes to finish playing. Don’t over-think or over-complicate.

Introducing the Project
To start this project, I give my students a brief introduction to 3D printing and TinkerCAD. Each individual student then has to design three mini projects to practice designing and 3D printing. They vary a bit each time, but the general idea are:
- A keychain with a raised feature (to practice adding holes and raising features to different areas)
- A shape with textures on the sides (to practice adding to different planes of a shape, and to practice using a variety of shapes)
- A cookie cutter, stencil or container (to practice adding and merging holes into shapes)
After we wrap up the practice projects, students move on to the Brainstorm/Ideation phase. The develop a mood board by gathering (non-AI) images of board games for inspiration. Then they create a sketch of the idea that they are working on. Their brainstorm sketch includes the name of the project, a brief description of how they plan for it to work, what they plan for it to teach and what elements will be 3D printed.

Starting the Build
I always like to have students build a mini-prototype (think something that can fit in a shoebox) before moving on to the larger project. This helps them avoid getting overcommitted into an idea that ends up not working. For this project, they make a mini-version of the game board and a few of the pieces. They also need to make a recycled prototype for their 3D printed element before moving on to designing in TinkerCAD. This helps them to get a better idea of measurements and proportions.
As students begin building their prototypes and creating their 3D designs, I check in with each group to see where they are at and where they are struggling. I have each group explain to me how their game will work and how it will teach the players about the topic. Sometimes this is where a little prompting and re-direction is needed. Some groups will create games that teach a skill rather than facts. Some will barely incorporate another topic just to meet the requirement. The idea behind the game is that the players will come away with something new after playing.
Some examples in the past have included:
- Trivia facts about the color purple
- The various stages of the life of a baseball player (little league, travel ball, college scouts, etc)
- How day trading works and how to know when to buy or sell
- How to identify different types of fish and what baits to use
With a little gentle encouragement, most students are able to find a way to bring their topic into the game, especially since it can be anything they have an interest in.

Testing and Refining
Since this is a highly interactive project, it really helps for students to have others test and play their games and provide feedback. I usually send out a call for other classes and teachers to come try out their games. This year we had an AP Business class from the high school come to test them out, which was fantastic because they were already learning about prototypes in their class.
As these guests try out the games, it helps my students to see what needs changing or refining. Are the instructions unclear or confusing? Does the game take too long to play? Are there additional pieces they didn’t think of that they need to create (i.e. score sheets, game money/tokens, etc)?
After the testing, students have a few more days to refine their projects and prepare for their presentations.

Presentation, Reflection, Grading
My procedures for presentations, reflection and grading are pretty much the same for every project, so check out this post over here for details. For this project, students created slides, presented to the class and guests, and then reflected by answering questions on a Formative.
For more ideas about using Design Challenges in your makerspace, check out the book I co-wrote with Colleen Graves and Aaron Graves, Challenge Based Learning in the School Library Makerspace.
Have you ever done a board game design challenge with your students? Tell me about it in the comments.